A congressman asked Mark Zuckerberg if ‘Facemash’ was still up and running

Posted on April 12, 2018 11:31 am CDT

By Steve Annear - The Boston Globe,

What you post on the Internet is forever — even for the guy who harbors much of the world’s personal information.

On Wednesday, during his second day of testimony before Congress about the Cambridge Analytica scandal, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg was asked by Representative Billy Long of Missouri whether a long-ago project — one that preceded Facebook — is still in existence.

“I’d like to ask before I go into my questioning,” Long said during the House Energy and Commerce Committee hearing Wednesday, “what was Facemash, and is it still up and running?”

If “Facemash” sounds familiar, it should. The project was highlighted in the 2010 film “The Social Network,” based on Facebook’s roots, and is perhaps the earliest example of Zuckerberg’s access to people’s personal information online.

It was cobbled together by Zuckerberg after a night of drinking while still a student at Harvard, according to a blog he kept at the time. The premise of the site was to let users on campus compare images of two women, side by side, and then vote on which one was most attractive.

Zuckerberg pieced together the site after scraping information from the university’s online facebook directory, a move that landed him before the school’s Administrative Board, according to a 2003 Harvard Crimson article.

He was accused of “breaching security, violating copyrights and violating individual privacy by creating the website,” the story said.

Long’s inquiry was lobbed at the Facebook bigwig as part of a series of questions to “better understand what happens to our personal information online,” he said on Twitter before the hearing.

Zuckerberg answered the question about Facemash’s history while appearing to stifle a chortle. He then brushed off the site as nothing more than an immature joke between a few friends.

“Facemash was a prank website that I launched in college — in my dorm room — before I started Facebook,” he said. “There was a movie about this — or it said it was about this — it was of unclear truth.”

Zuckerberg later said Facemash and the website that billions of people use today have no relation.

“The claim that Facemash was somehow connected to the development of Facebook — it isn’t, it wasn’t, and Facemash isn’t running,” he said. “Actually, it has nothing to do with Facebook.”

Seeking clarity, Long asked Zuckerberg if his interpretation of Facemash was on target, a question that led to a brief and awkward pause from Zuckerberg.

“You put up pictures of two women and decide which one was a better, more attractive of the two, is that right?” Long said.

Zuckerberg replied, “Congressman, that is an accurate description of the prank website that I made when I was a sophomore in college.”

The preliminary questioning about Facemash shifted, as Long asked about how Facebook deems what’s “unsafe” for users to view on the platform.

He also gave Zuckerberg a warning.

“Congress is good at two things: doing nothing and overreacting,” Long said. “So far, we’ve done nothing on Facebook. Since your inception in that Harvard dorm room, many years ago, we’ve done nothing on Facebook. We’re getting ready to overreact. So take that as just a shot across the bow.”


Contribute to the Campaign

Please consider making a contribution today to support Billy’s quest to bring real conservative values to Washington.

Get Started »

Join Us

If you would like to access the members-only areas of the Billy Long for Congress web site or leave us information on how can volunteer, please take the time to share your details with us.

Join The Team! »

Stay Connected

Stay connected to the latest campaign updates and discussions by following Billy on his Facebook page or following Billy’s tweets on twitter.